Original 'Practical Magic' Cast Member Responds to Sequel Recasting Backlash
Entertainment

Original 'Practical Magic' Cast Member Responds to Sequel Recasting Backlash

authorBy Shonda Rhimes
DateSep 06, 2026
Read Time2 min

In the wake of Evan Rachel Wood's public comments regarding the recasting of her role in the upcoming sequel to 'Practical Magic,' Alexandra Artrip, another original cast member, has weighed in on the ongoing conversation. Artrip, who portrayed Antonia, the younger daughter of Sandra Bullock's character Sally Owens in the 1998 movie, spoke out after Maisie Williams and Joey King were announced as the new actors for the sequel, taking on the roles of Antonia and Kylie, respectively.

Artrip, now retired from acting, utilized Instagram to address the fan backlash concerning the recasting decisions. She acknowledged the supportive intent behind fans' criticisms for her and Wood, as well as their affection for the original film. However, Artrip emphasized her desire to keep her online presence free from negativity, praising Williams and King as talented performers and expressing confidence in the production team's choices for the film's success. She encouraged viewers to approach the sequel with an open mind, asserting that the original film's essence would remain untouched, and expressed excitement for the expansion of the 'Practical Magic' universe.

This discussion follows Wood's earlier revelation that she was not asked to return for the sequel, despite offering her participation even in a minor capacity. She conveyed her regret to fans but clarified that the decision was beyond her control, later extending her best wishes to Joey King for taking on the role of Kylie. King, in a recent interview, shared that she had a positive conversation with Wood, expressing her appreciation for Wood's support and acknowledging the significant contribution Wood made to the character in the original movie. The sequel will see the return of original stars Sandra Bullock, Nicole Kidman, Dianne Wiest, and Stockard Channing, and is set to be released on September 11.

The discourse surrounding recasting in beloved film sequels often highlights the deep connection audiences form with original portrayals. While it's natural for fans to feel a sense of nostalgia and attachment, embracing new interpretations can breathe fresh life into cherished stories. Such transitions remind us of the evolving nature of storytelling and the opportunity to appreciate new artistic contributions, fostering a spirit of openness and growth within the cinematic world.

More Articles
Entertainment
May el-Toukhy Addresses Gender Disparity in Film Industry at Venice Film Festival
Danish director May el-Toukhy, the sole female director in competition at the Venice Film Festival for her film 'Woman Unknown,' voiced concerns about the prevalent gender gap in the film industry. She highlighted the systemic issues faced by female filmmakers from film school to production and beyond, noting the disparity in how male and female directors are perceived and described.
By Roger EbertSep 06, 2026
Entertainment
Eleanor Coppola's 'Making Marie Antoinette': A Cinematic Chronicle of Mother-Daughter Collaboration
Eleanor Coppola's documentary, 'Making Marie Antoinette,' offers an intimate look into the creation of Sofia Coppola's 2006 film. Utilizing 80 hours of behind-the-scenes footage, the film explores the artistic and familial bond between mother and daughter. It delves into the challenges of a large-scale production, Sofia's creative vision, and Eleanor's unique perspective as an insider. The documentary, completed posthumously by Sofia as a tribute to her mother, highlights Eleanor's distinct artistic voice and her fascination with the filmmaking process.
By Guillermo del ToroSep 06, 2026
Entertainment
Wim Wenders Clarifies Filmmakers' Political Stance: Art as an Antidote, Not Politics
Wim Wenders has once again addressed the controversy sparked at the Berlin Film Festival regarding his comments on filmmakers' involvement in politics. He reiterated that artists act as an 'antidote' to politics by fostering empathy, contrasting with the political sphere's often unempathetic approach. His recent remarks at the Venice Film Festival aimed to clarify his original statement, emphasizing the distinct roles of art and governance.
By Ta-Nehisi CoatesSep 06, 2026
Entertainment
Lee Chang-dong's 'Possible Love': A Deep Dive into Social Class, Human Desire, and Cinematic Reunions
Korean auteur Lee Chang-dong's latest film, 'Possible Love,' explores complex themes of societal stratification, unspoken desires, and enduring relationships. Featuring a reunion with stars Jeon Do-yeon and Sul Kyung-gu, the Venice competition entry delves into the lives of two couples whose paths intertwine amidst economic turmoil, prompting profound questions about love's true nature and the ethics of storytelling.
By John LasseterSep 06, 2026
Entertainment
Julianne Moore's Stellar Performance in 'The Debut' Captivates Telluride Film Festival, Igniting Oscar Buzz
Jesse Eisenberg's latest directorial effort, 'The Debut,' has premiered to critical acclaim at the Telluride Film Festival, with Julianne Moore's performance hailed as a career-best. The film, a darkly comedic and emotionally resonant exploration of community theater, is poised as a strong contender for the upcoming Academy Awards, particularly for its lead actors. Paul Giamatti also delivers a memorable turn, reinforcing the film's potential for awards season success.
By Guillermo del ToroSep 06, 2026